(PhysOrg.com) --
Schizophrenia may blur the boundary between internal and external realities by
over-activating a brain system that is involved in self-reflection, and thus
causing an exaggerated focus on self, a new MIT and Harvard brain imaging study
has found.
The traditional view of schizophrenia is that the disturbed thoughts, perceptions and emotions that characterize the disease are caused by disconnections among the brain regions that control these different functions.
But this study, appearing Jan. 19 in the advance online issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, found that schizophrenia also involves an excess of connectivity between the so-called default brain regions, which are involved in self-reflection and become active when we are thinking about nothing in particular, or thinking about ourselves.
"People normally suppress this default system when they perform challenging tasks, but we found that patients with schizophrenia don't do this," said John D. Gabrieli, a professor in the McGovern Institute for Brain Research at MIT and one of the study's 13 authors. "We think this could help to explain the cognitive and psychological symptoms of schizophrenia."
Gabrieli added that he hopes the research might lead to ways of predicting or monitoring individual patients' response to treatments for this mental illness, which occurs in about 1 percent of the population.
Schizophrenia has a strong genetic component, and first-degree relatives of patients (who share half their genes) are 10 times more likely to develop the disease than the general population. The identities of these genes and how they affect the brain are largely unknown.
The researchers thus studied three carefully matched groups of 13 subjects each: schizophrenia patients, nonpsychotic first-degree relatives of patients and healthy controls. They selected patients who were recently diagnosed, so that differences in prior treatment or psychotic episodes would not bias the results.
The subjects were scanned by functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) while resting and while performing easy or hard memory tasks. The behavioral and clinical testing were performed by Larry J. Seidman and colleagues at Harvard Medical School, and the imaging data were analyzed by first author Susan Whitfield-Gabrieli, a research scientist at the MIT Martinos Imaging Center at the McGovern Institute.
The researchers were especially interested in the default system, a network of brain regions whose activity is suppressed when people perform demanding mental tasks. This network includes the medial prefrontal cortex and the posterior cingulate cortex, regions that are associated with self-reflection and autobiographical memories and which become connected into a synchronously active network when the mind is allowed to wander.
Whitfield-Gabrieli found that in the schizophrenia patients, the default system was both hyperactive and hyperconnected during rest, and it remained so as they performed the memory tasks. In other words, the patients were less able than healthy control subjects to suppress the activity of this network during the task. Interestingly, the less the suppression and the greater the connectivity, the worse they performed on the hard memory task, and the more severe their clinical symptoms.
"We think this may reflect an inability of people with schizophrenia to direct mental resources away from internal thoughts and feelings and toward the external world in order to perform difficult tasks," Whitfield-Gabrieli explained.
The hyperactive default system could also help to explain hallucinations and paranoia by making neutral external stimuli seem inappropriately self-relevant. For instance, if brain regions whose activity normally signifies self-focus are active while listening to a voice on television, the person may perceive that the voice is speaking directly to them.
The default system is also overactive, though to a lesser extent, in first-degree relatives of schizophrenia patients who did not themselves have the disease. This suggests that overactivation of the default system may be linked to the genetic cause of the disease rather than its consequences.
The default system is a hot topic in brain imaging, according to John Gabrieli, partly because it is easy to measure and because it is affected in different ways by different disorders.
background material to thought disorder
default brain
default brain
G. H. Brans, MS, N E. M. van Haren, PhD, G. M. van Baal, PhD, W G. Staal, PhD, MD, HG. Schnack, PhD, R S. Kahn, PhD, MD and H E. Hulshoff Pol, PhD University Medical Center Utrecht, The Netherlands
The progressive decreases over time in whole brain and cerebral grey matter volume [ the cells ]
and less prominent increases in white matter [ the joining connecting lines ] observed in schizophrenia patients
but not in siblings may represent a (disease-related) non-genetic risk factor for the disease.
Our finding of progressive decrease over time is consistent with those of other longitudinal studies in schizophrenia.
The findings in siblings are consistent with the normalisation of cortical thickness
by the age of 20 in siblings of patients with childhood-onset schizophrenia.
Could it be disuse ? How otherwise to find late 'recoveries - unless another pathway is found to get round the grey matter loss ?
mica@jidgey.e7even.com
Time course of regional brain activation associated with onset of auditory/verbal hallucinations.
Hoffman,
Department of Psychiatry, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut :
Anderson, M Varanko, JC. Gore,
Two sites exhibiting positive BOLD [ blood oxygen up levels becasue of activity in local cells ] signal correlations with hallucination time course exclusively at negative time lags [ occuring so many seconds before hallucinating ] largely replicated pre-hallucination activation sites described previously.
Positive Blood Oxygen signal correlations with hallucination time course were detected selectively at negative time intervals ( time lags ranging from -4.5 s to -1.5 s) in the left insula and a right middle temporal region, as well as in left pre-central areas .
Positive correlations also emerged in the superior temporal gyrus bilaterally at negative time lags, ( then ) peaking approximately at zero time lag [ i.e. the same time as hallucinating ]
Negative blood oxygen signal correlations with hallucination time course were detected in the right ventral anterior cingulate , and left parahippocampal gyri at negative time lags.
Right middle temporal site
The right middle temporal site (Brodmann area 21) was located remarkably close to middle temporal gyrus sites of pre-hallucination activation reported by Lennox et al and Shergill et al.
Activation in the bilateral superior temporal gyrus (Brodmann area 22) emerged at negative time lags also [ i'e .. 'before ] , but peaked later and was broadly distributed over both positive and negative time lags.
Our correlation-based method for mapping BOLD signal time course will produce temporal smearing that broadens with increasing neural activation.
The temporal pattern of our data suggests therefore that the more robust bilateral activation in the superior temporal gyrus arose somewhat later - perhaps at hallucination onset - than the middle temporal gyrus activation.
Bilateral activation of the latter region has been associated with aspects of verbal comprehension during speech processing distinct from acoustic feature detection referable to the superior temporal gyrus, whereas non-dominant middle temporal gyral activation has been associated with detecting prosodic features of spoken speech.
One plausible account of our findings is that pre-hallucination activation in the middle temporal gyrus reflecting verbal content and/or prosody [ the study of poetic meters, metrics and versification - the stress and intonation patterns of an utterance
] is subsequently propagated to the superior temporal gyrus via top-down processing, which generates ( hallucinated) acoustic representations. [ 'voices' ]
Left anterior insula
The left anterior insula was close to a site of activation in the left inferior frontal gyrus 9 , prior to hallucination onset, identified by Shergill et al, who reported expanded activation incorporating the left insula at later times.
Left insula activation has been associated with speech articulation, imagining spoken speech of others, and focused auditory attention,
suggesting that pre-hallucination insula activation reflects inner speech
or auditory imagery generation as previously hypothesised, or enhanced auditory attention.
However, pre-hallucination insula activation might instead reflect motor movement required to signal these events.
This possibility is suggested by the fact that doing simple finger movements
is preceded by activation in the adjacent Broca's area, which has been postulated to reflect mental preparation.
Other sites
Evidence of right ventral anterior cingulate and left parahippocampal deactivation preceding hallucination onset was detected.
Co-occurring deactivations in these regions have also been linked to heightened vigilance/attention, suggesting a shift in cognitive state preceding auditory/verbal hallucinations.
Along these lines, Arieti described a `listening attitude' that predisposes people with schizophrenia to hear `voices'.
Pre-central activation emerging prior to hallucination onset in our study could reflect either inner speech generation or signalling hallucinations by finger movement.
In summary, activation detected as BOLD signal changes correlated with auditory/verbal hallucination time course at negative time lags may reveal complex brain processes triggering these experiences.
Future studies of this type would be advanced by controlling for effects of motor behaviour [ the other explanation preparing whatever motor required to signal hallucination occurrences.
To me this means that activity goes on in the area of the brain dealing with 'hearing' hallucinatory voices before there is activity in the areas of the brain that do speech or silent speech ?
People with autism are supposed not to do 'day dreaming'. What about people with schizophrenia - anybody know ??? How will day dreaming fit in with the above.
People in schizophrenia are often in a state of doing nothing - the default state of daydreaming.
Then, when actually 'paying attention' e.g at a professional interview
when it is important to be paying attention, because of the possible consequences ...
...that seems to be when the 'voices' are not there or are disregarded.
Similarly when taken up with concentrating on doing something connected with 'outside the person ' activities.
What about the 'fantasy dreaming that goes on ? when 'dozing' on the way to sleep,
or being half to waking up ?? Help ??